Accepted Items


  • The 150 pieces of clothing do not include shoes, socks, or bibs.
  • A 2- or 3-piece set, like a shirt and shorts that is grouped as a set on one hanger, counts as one piece.
  • No more than 3 items allowed on one hanger.
    • NOTE: An exception to this is if the items are part of an outfit. (ex. shirt, pants, vest, and a hat)
  • No more than 20 can be size 0 – 6mos.
    • Preemie outfits are not included in the 20-piece limit
    • We are typically over-run with these sizes and have had many complaints from shoppers that these sizes contain duplicate outfits.
    • A group of onesies can be pinned together (and not hung on a hanger) to be placed on a table and DO NOT count towards the limit for 0–6 months.
    • If an item is labeled “6 months,” it will go on the 6-9 month rack and is not subject to the 20-item limit.


Clothing must be seasonally appropriate. Please bring your best gently worn children’s clothing (infant through girls/boys size 18 and teens from size 0 and up)!

Accepted during our Spring/Summer events:

  • Bathing suits
  • Tank tops
  • Holiday attire and accessories – Fourth of July, Easter
  • Seasonally-themed books, games, etc.

Accepted during our Fall/Winter events:

  • Heavy jackets/coats
  • Holiday attire – Thanksgiving, Halloween, Christmas
  • Halloween Costumes and accessories
  • Seasonally-themed books, games, etc.

Accepted year-round:

  • Jeans are accepted year-round.
  • Teen clothing is accepted! Limit for teen is 25 hung items for teens.
  • Shoes: We are limiting shoes to 8 pairs for children and 4 pairs for teens.
    • NOTE: They must look like new.

We will not accept items that are stained, ripped, faded, or have missing buttons, etc. No out of date styles – it won’t sell!

Other Items

All items should be CLEAN and in working condition!! If an item is missing something (ex., a board game missing a piece) note it on the tag!!

  • Toys, video games, bikes, puzzles (no missing pieces), games, ride-on toys, sporting goods.
  • Books/videos including current home school curriculum.
    • NOTE: CDS, DVDs, etc. Please make sure that the correct item is in the correct case.
  • Batteries must be included in all battery-operated toys.
  • Play equipment (HIGH DEMAND) – MUST be clean!!
    • Examples: Playhouses, picnic tables, etc.
  • Baby equipment such as strollers, swings, bouncy seats, exersaucers, etc.
  • Children’s furniture including gliding rockers, chest, beds, changing tables, etc.
  • Cribs, Play Yards, High Chairs, and Strollers
    • These items sell exceptionally well. However, they sell best when assembled. If you plan on bringing a similar item, please allow enough time at drop off to assemble these yourself at the sale. 
  • Crib bedding, children’s bedding & accessories – must be clean and stain-free!
  • Breast pumps (motor only; please remove used tubing).
  • Humidifiers – must be clean and free of mold/mildew. 



After dozens of strangulation and entrapment-related deaths and injuries, the federal government has put its foot down on the subject of drop-sided cribs, proclaiming them illegal for sale in the U.S. In a unanimous vote, the Consumer Product Safety Commission this month decided to make the manufacture, sale and resale of traditional drop-sided cribs illegal. THEREFORE: We will no longer accept drop-sided cribs.


  • Clothing which is outdated (e.g., over 5 yrs. old), faded, has stains, tears, or holes.
  • We are no longer accepting maternity clothing.
  • Large bags filled with onesies, socks, bibs, etc. Please use the pages listed under the Consign tab the top of this page for the correct way to sell these items.
  • We no longer accept VHS tapes.
  • Stuffed animals (unless popular characters – Disney, Sesame Street, Dora, Build-a-Bear, etc. – LIMIT 2).
  • Grab bags of small Happy Meal/Arcade type toys
  • Perishables, such as formula, baby food, baby cereal, etc. are no longer accepted.
  • If selling bottles, please remove the nipples!
  • Unless new in sealed package:
    • Nipples for baby bottles
    • Pacifiers
    • Bath tubs/bath seats
    • Diaper Genies
    • Potties/Potty seats

For insurance reasons, we cannot accept or sell used car seats, booster seats, or car seat bases.

NOTE: Infant car seats that are part of a travel system set will be accepted. Only car seats manufactured within the past 5 years will be accepted. PLEASE DO NOT SELL A CAR SEAT THAT HAS BEEN IN AN AUTO ACCIDENT!

If you have any questions about what is acceptable, please do not hesitate to email us at info@finderskeepersjax.com.

Consignor Tips

  • Place consignor number on all items if possible, especially toys and sets that have multiple pieces (use masking tapes or small labels).
  • Secure loose/small toy items in bags and tape shut.
  • All electronic toys must be working with batteries installed.
  • When compiling clothing sets, make sure both items are the SAME size.
  • Price to sell and discount items to 50% on Saturday, when possible!
  • Choose correct colored card for your tagging, including toys, books, DVDs, puzzles, etc. (WHITE cards indicate “donate;” COLORED cards indicate “return to consignor”).
  • Use zipties to secure shoes.

Important Dates

Tuesday, Nov 29
Finders Keepers Fanatics Presale
Finders Keepers Cares Presale

Wednesday, Nov 30
Heroes Presale
Healthcare Heroes Presale

Public Sale
Wednesday, Nov 30
Thursday, Dec 1

Half Price Sales
(many items 50% off)
Friday, Dec 2
Finders Keepers Fanatics
Half Off Presale

Open to the public:
Friday, Dec 2
Saturday, Dec 3

Consignor Registration
October 2 – November 23

Consignor Registration

Join Our Email List!

Shopping Tips

  • Bring bags, baskets, or any large tote to carry your items.
  • We accept Cash, AmEx, Discover, MC, Visa. NO CHECKS PLEASE!
  • When purchasing large items that have a claim ticket, tear off bottom and hand to room attendant.
  • We offer a “hold” area for items to be placed while you’re shopping (2 hr max).
  • SATURDAY only, if label reads “No Disc” then those items are full price, everything else is 50%.